What went wrong?
My darkroom prints look flat and muddy
What you're seeing
Greyish blacks, dull highlights and low contrast, even though the negative looks fine. The borders may still look white.
Check this first
Check this first
Check you developed for the full datasheet time at 20°C. If you did, make a print one filter grade harder before you blame anything else.
Likely causes, most common first
- 01
Contrast filter too soft for the negative
Common- How to tell
- Borders are clean white and the developer is fresh, but the print has neither a real black nor a clean white highlight.
- Test it
- Make two prints of the same negative, one with filter 2 and one with filter 3 or 3½, developed for the same full time. If the harder one looks right, contrast was the problem.
- The fix
- Use a higher Multigrade filter. Ilford advises filter 3 or higher when a print looks too grey and lacks solid blacks or clean whites. Filters 4 to 5 need about double the exposure of the lower filters.
Sources Ilford Photo / Harman technology, Making your first black & white print (information sheet); HARMAN technology / Ilford Photo, MULTIGRADE RC Papers Technical Information (Oct 2020, 'J20')
- 02
Print pulled from the developer too early
Common- How to tell
- The image came up and you took it out when it looked right. Blacks are weak and greyish rather than the whole print being veiled.
- Test it
- Make two identical prints. Develop one for the datasheet time and one for half that. If the half-time print matches your problem prints, you have been underdeveloping.
- The fix
- Time development, don't judge by eye. Ilford says the image appears within seconds but needs the full time to mature: 1 minute for Multigrade RC in Multigrade developer 1+9, and 1½ to 3 minutes for fibre. Ilford notes fibre can go to 6 minutes without a noticeable change in contrast or fog.
Sources Ilford Photo / Harman technology, Making your first black & white print (information sheet); HARMAN technology / Ilford Photo, MULTIGRADE RC Papers Technical Information (Oct 2020, 'J20'); HARMAN technology / Ilford Photo, MULTIGRADE FB CLASSIC Technical Information (Oct 2013); ILFORD Imaging UK Limited, Processing and Finishing ILFORD Fibre Base Papers (Fact Sheet, December 2001)
- 03
Exhausted, cold or over-diluted developer
Occasional- How to tell
- The image is slow to appear and the blacks never get deep, even with longer exposure. With fresh Multigrade developer 1+9 the image starts to appear after about 10 seconds on Multigrade RC and about 20 seconds on Multigrade FB Classic.
- Test it
- Time how long the image takes to appear on a test strip in your working developer, then in freshly mixed developer at 20°C. A much slower start in the old tray means it is tired or cold.
- The fix
- Mix fresh developer at 20°C. Ilford gives a capacity of about 50 8x10in fibre prints per litre of Multigrade developer at 1+9, and an open-tray life of two working days at 1+9 or one day at 1+14.
Sources HARMAN technology / Ilford Photo, MULTIGRADE RC Papers Technical Information (Oct 2020, 'J20'); HARMAN technology / Ilford Photo, MULTIGRADE FB CLASSIC Technical Information (Oct 2013); ILFORD Imaging UK Limited, Processing and Finishing ILFORD Fibre Base Papers (Fact Sheet, December 2001); Ilford Photo / Harman technology, Making your first black & white print (information sheet)
- 04
Low-level safelight fog
Occasional- How to tell
- Highlights look veiled and contrast is lower, but the borders can still look white. Kodak and Ilford both say safelight exposure degrades highlights and lowers contrast before border fog becomes visible.
- Test it
- Do the full safelight test from Kodak K-4 or Ilford: give part of a sheet a pale grey enlarger exposure, then give it steps of safelight exposure (for example 0, 1, 2 and 4 minutes), and develop in darkness. A coin on a blank sheet is not enough: Kodak says it tests only for fog, not for the combined effect of safelight and enlarger exposure.
- The fix
- Use the recommended filter and bulb (Ilford: SL1 or 902 with a 15 W bulb at least 1.2 m away, safe for up to 4 minutes), replace faded filters, and keep paper face down and away from the safelight.
Sources Eastman Kodak Company, How Safe Is Your Safelight? A Guide to Darkroom Illumination; HARMAN technology / Ilford Photo, Safelight Filters and Darkroom Lamps (Technical Information, June 2010); Ilford Photo (HARMAN technology), Testing your safelights (Expert Series, posted 31 March 2017); HARMAN technology / Ilford Photo, MULTIGRADE RC Papers Technical Information (Oct 2020, 'J20')
Avoiding it next time
- Time every print in the developer for the full datasheet time.
- Test your safelights once a year and whenever you change a bulb or filter.
- Mix fresh print developer for each session and keep it at 20°C.