Skip to main content

Film comparison

Foma Bohemia Fomapan 200 Creative vs Ilford HP5 Plus

  • HP5 Plus is a stop faster (ISO 400 vs 200).
  • Fomapan 200 Creative has finer grain.
  • HP5 Plus is more forgiving of exposure errors.
  • Fomapan 200 Creative is cheaper in 35mm (about £6.95 vs £10.81).
Open in the compare tool

Side by side

SpecificationFomapan 200 CreativeHP5 Plus
ManufacturerFoma BohemiaIlford
TypeBlack & whiteBlack & white
Box speedISO 200ISO 400
ProcessB&WB&W
Formats35mm, 12035mm, 120, 4x5, 8x10
GrainFineMedium
Contrast—Medium
LatitudeGoodExcellent
Saturation——
Price, 35mmabout £6.95about £10.81
Price, 120about £5.99about £9.20
AvailabilityCurrentCurrent

Rows that differ are in bold. Prices are typical UK prices and change often.

How they look

Fomapan 200 Creative
Modern cubic-and-T-crystal emulsion with high resolving power (Foma datasheet: RMS 14.0, close to Fomapan 100). Rated ISO 200/24; the maker says it gives good results from EI 100 (one stop over) to EI 800 (two stops under) with no change in development.
HP5 Plus
Robust all-purpose ISO 400 film with a wide exposure latitude; Ilford's datasheet gives good results from EI 200 to 800 and push processing to EI 3200 with extended development.

Which suits what

Better pick: Fomapan 200 Creative

Students, Experiments

Both work well

General purpose

Better pick: HP5 Plus

Education, Street

Long exposures (reciprocity)

MeteredFomapan 200 CreativeHP5 Plus
1s3s1s
10s1m 30s20s
30s6m 16s1m 26s
2mNo data8m 49s

Corrected exposure from each film’s published reciprocity data. Reciprocity calculator

Developing both