Film comparison
Ilford HP5 Plus vs Kodak Tri-X 400
- Tri-X 400 has more contrast.
Side by side
| Specification | HP5 Plus | Tri-X 400 |
|---|---|---|
| Manufacturer | Ilford | Kodak |
| Type | Black & white | Black & white |
| Box speed | ISO 400 | ISO 400 |
| Process | B&W | B&W |
| Formats | 35mm, 120, 4x5, 8x10 | 35mm, 120 |
| Grain | Medium | Medium |
| Contrast | Medium | High |
| Latitude | Excellent | Excellent |
| Saturation | — | — |
| Price, 35mm | about £10.81 | about £11.27 |
| Price, 120 | about £9.20 | about £12.95 |
| Availability | Current | Current |
Rows that differ are in bold. Prices are typical UK prices and change often.
How they look
- HP5 Plus
- Robust all-purpose ISO 400 film with a wide exposure latitude; Ilford's datasheet gives good results from EI 200 to 800 and push processing to EI 3200 with extended development.
- Tri-X 400
- High-speed panchromatic film that Kodak recommends for dim light, fast action and push processing (F-4017). Traditional cubic-grain emulsion known for photojournalism; re-engineered with finer grain in 2007 (Wikipedia list).
Which suits what
Better pick: HP5 Plus
Education, General purpose
Both work well
Street
Better pick: Tri-X 400
Documentary, Push processing
Long exposures (reciprocity)
| Metered | HP5 Plus | Tri-X 400 |
|---|---|---|
| 1s | 1s | 2s |
| 10s | 20s | 50s |
| 30s | 1m 26s | 3m 48s |
| 2m | 8m 49s | No data |
Corrected exposure from each film’s published reciprocity data. Reciprocity calculator
Developing both
Developers with published times for both films:
HP5 Plus
510-Pyro
9:00
1+100 · EI 400 · 20°C · 2 variants
D-76
7:30
Stock · EI 400 · 20°C · 6 variants
Df96 Monobath
6:00
Stock · EI 400 · 21°C
Diafine
6:00
Stock · EI 800 · 20°C · 2 variants
HC-110
5:00
1+31 · EI 400 · 20°C · 7 variants
PMK Pyro
13:00
1+2+100 · EI 400 · 21.1°C · 2 variants
Rodinal
6:00
1+25 · EI 400 · 20°C · 4 variants
T-Max Developer
6:30
1+4 · EI 400 · 20°C · 4 variants
XTOL
8:00
Stock · EI 400 · 20°C · 6 variants
Tri-X 400
510-Pyro
16:25
1+100 · EI 400 · 20°C · 4 variants
D-76
6:45
Stock · EI 400 · 20°C · 21 variants
Df96 Monobath
6:00
Stock · EI 400 · 21°C
Diafine
6:00
Stock · EI 1600 · 20°C
HC-110
3:45
1+31 · EI 400 · 20°C · 6 variants
PMK Pyro
14:00
1+2+100 · EI 260 · 21.1°C
Rodinal
7:00
1+25 · EI 400 · 20°C · 3 variants
T-Max Developer
6:00
1+4 · EI 400 · 20°C · 7 variants
XTOL
7:00
Stock · EI 400 · 20°C · 18 variants