Skip to main content

What went wrong?

My negatives are thin and weak

Negatives and slides

What you're seeing

Images are faint, shadows are empty and clear, and scans look grainy and muddy.

A thin negative held against a light, with a normal and a dense one for comparison. Compare your own strip with these.

Check this first

Check this first

Compare the edge markings with a roll you know was developed correctly.

Likely causes, most common first

  1. 01

    Underexposure

    Common
    How to tell
    The edge markings are strong and normal, but the shadows have no detail. Highlights may still look reasonable.
    Test it
    Shoot a test roll of a still scene, bracketing one stop either side of the meter reading, and develop it normally. If the extra-exposure frames look right, your meter or ISO setting is the problem.
    The fix
    Check the ISO setting and the meter. Expose a test roll to find the film speed that gives you good shadow detail with your camera and developer.

    Sources Ilford Photo (Harman Technology), Common Processing Problems; Kodak Alaris, Kodak Professional TRI-X 320 and 400 Films Technical Data (F-4017, rev. 12-16)

  2. 02

    Underdevelopment

    Common
    How to tell
    The edge markings are faint too, and the whole roll lacks contrast, with weak highlights as well as shadows.
    Test it
    Check your time, temperature and dilution against the data sheet, and check your thermometer against a second one.
    The fix
    Develop for the full time at the right temperature and dilution, with the agitation the data sheet gives. Below 20°C you need a longer time: use the maker's temperature chart.

    Sources Ilford Photo (Harman Technology), Common Processing Problems; Ilford Photo, Ilford: Processing your first black & white film (information leaflet, Oct 2003)

  3. 03

    Tired or exhausted developer

    Occasional
    How to tell
    Edge markings are weak, and the problem got worse over several rolls developed in the same reused or old developer.
    Test it
    Develop a short test piece in fresh developer alongside one in your old developer and compare the edge markings.
    The fix
    Mix fresh developer and keep to the capacity and storage life on the data sheet.

    Sources Eastman Kodak Company, Processing KODAK Motion Picture Films, Module 15: Processing Black-and-White Films; Eastman Kodak Company, Processing Chemicals and Formulas for Black-and-White Photography (Kodak Publication J-1), 7th edition

Avoiding it next time

  • Use a thermometer and the temperature chart for your developer.
  • Keep to the developer's capacity and storage life.
  • Shoot a test roll when you change film, developer or camera.

Go deeper